Colombia's largest hydroelectric plant wasn't supposed to be financed the way it ended up being financed. The original plan was a project finance structure: an independent vehicle, a group of banks lending against the plant's future cash flows and, along with them, an army of advisors reviewing every decision. Engineers looking at the technical side, specialists on the environmental side, lawyers on the legal side, analysts on the financial side.
When the size and complexity of the deal became clear, its owner took another path: it moved the plant onto its own balance sheet and financed it directly, at lower rates and with far fewer questions. It was the fastest decision and the cheapest one.
What came next is well known. Cost overruns, accidents, and years of problems weighing on the company's books.
No one can know what would have happened on the other path. But one of the lawyers who worked on the original structure has a clear view: the banks' demanding scrutiny would probably have prevented many of the mistakes.
What outside eyes buy you
That lawyer is Juan Carlos Puentes, a partner at Cuatrecasas, and that structure was his first big assignment, at 21, freshly arrived on his firm's finance team. On All You Can Debt, he explained why he values project finance so much, beyond the money: the number of outside eyes it puts on a deal. He calls them police. Someone asking whether something makes technical sense, another whether it makes environmental sense, another legal sense, another financial sense.
None of them guarantees success. There's always construction risk, and something nobody foresaw always shows up. But a project that has to convince four independent sets of eyes every time it makes a decision makes fewer mistakes than one that only has to convince itself.
Cheap financing is often cheap for the same reason it's dangerous: it comes with fewer police.
The temptation to close fast
The police are also uncomfortable, and Juan Carlos knows it from the inside. Clients arrive with the deal already closed in their heads and a single instruction: close it, we need to disburse tomorrow. No advisor wants to be the one putting up roadblocks.
He shared a recent case. He asked something basic: why the deal was structured as a purchase of receivables and not as a plain loan. No one could answer. For fifteen days, the client and its counterparty passed the question back and forth, until the reason surfaced: a tax issue. On review, the benefit no longer applied, because the regulation had changed. All the work done up to that point had to start over.
That's the uncomfortable value of a good question asked in time. It costs fifteen days. Not asking it can cost the entire deal, or worse.
When no one is watching
Colombian structured credit has its own version of this story. A few years ago, the payroll lending market went through a scandal in which the same loans ended up sold to several lenders at once. According to Juan Carlos, part of the problem was that lenders' teams kept changing and the monitoring gradually fell by the wayside. That gave rise to a practice that is now standard in due diligence: checking that promissory notes and loan agreements aren't duplicated.
And he sets a limit on what rules can do: you can invent all the laws you want, and fraud won't end because of them. Changing that runs deeper and slower. In the meantime, what protects a lender is the same thing that protected the plant in its original plan: someone independent, actually looking.
The police that never leave
The problem with traditional police is that they depend on someone asking for them, paying for them, and remembering them when the team changes. At Vaas, we work so that oversight doesn't depend on any of that: we verify the existence, ownership, and cash flows of every asset against the source, every day, for the entire life of the loan.
Financing without police isn't cheaper. It just pays later.
The full conversation with Juan Carlos Puentes, including how you close a deal with a Chinese bank while working on Asian hours for months, what he learned in a program for international lawyers in Tokyo, and why he believes Colombia's usury rate ends up pushing people toward loan sharks, is on the episode of All You Can Debt.
▶️ YouTube: https://sl1nk.com/4zs3ulw
🎙️ Spotify: https://acesse.one/xplj4t3
How Vaas verifies the asset is actually there: https://getvaas.com